Applying usability engineering principles to the design and testing of warning messages
Publication Year:
1999
Citation
163. Wogalter, M. S., Conzola, V. C., & Vigilante, W. J. (1999). Applying usability engineering principles to the design and testing of warning messages. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 43, 921-925.
Abstract
wording. • Avoid using words or statements that might have multiple interpretations. Format • Use mixed case. Avoiding using all caps except for signal words. • Left-justify text. • Consistently position component elements. • Orient messages to read from left to right. Concentrate on communicating the necessary hazard information as clearly as possible. Once some prototype warnings have been created subject matter experts are recruited to evaluate the prototypes and offer suggestions for improvement. Both experts in the field of warnings and risk perception and domain experts with extensive knowledge of the environment and hazards under consideration should be included. Warnings experts are most qualified to evaluate the warnings against accepted design standards and guidelines. Domain experts will likely have additional input about hazards that were not considered in earliest versions of the warnings. In selecting experts avoid choosing individuals whose professional or financial standing might bias their opinions away from product safety and a desire to communicate product hazards. Rewrite the warnings as often as necessary based on the expert’s feedback. Try to combine the best features of the different versions into 2 or 3 warnings for each hazard that satisfy the experts requirements. Once the experts are satisfied, bring in individuals representative of the target population to evaluate the warning text. Explain the product’s purpose and the nature of all product hazards that have been identified. Instruct the evaluators to read each warning and identify portions of the text that they find difficult (or which they believe others may find difficult). In particular, evaluators should be asked to point out words, phrases, or sentences they do not understand or find ambiguous. Ask for ideas on how to better phrase the difficult parts of warnings. Rewrite the warning text as necessary based on evaluator feedback. Repeat this evaluation cycle until both evaluators and designers are confident that one version of each warning clearly communicates the appropriate level of hazard and provides instructions for safe behavior. EMPIRICAL USER TESTING Once a fairly stable design point has been reached and the prototype’s major problems have been identified and corrected the next step in the usability engineering process is to subject the design to more formal and comprehensive testing. For computer interfaces, representative users perform specific tasks that exercise portions of the interface that support key system functions. If the actual interface is not available because coding is not yet completed, a limited function but high fidelity mockup can be used instead. The goal of user testing is to identify deeper usability problems and to determine if pre-defined usability goals such as task completion times and error rates have been achieved. Similarly, once the prototype warnings have reached an acceptable level, more formal, quantitative testing of their effectiveness should be conducted before they are put into use. Individuals representative of the target population(s) should be used as test participants, including persons with lower levels of reading ability. As rule of thumb, at least 30 participants who were not involved in the prototyping activities should be used. Measures Measures that can be used to assess warning effectiveness include open-ended questions and rating scales.
Publication Details
- Source
- Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Volume
- 43
Publication Type
Conference Papers / Proceedings
Research Topics
Human-Computer Interaction & Usability, Warnings & Risk Communication
