On the risk of quiet vehicles to pedestrians and drivers

Wogalter, M. S.
Ornan, R. N.
Lim, R. W.
Chipley, M. R.
Publication Year: 2001

Citation

209.  Wogalter, M. S., Ornan, R. N., Lim, R. W., & Chipley, M. R. (2001). On the risk of quiet vehicles to pedestrians and drivers. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 45, 1685-1688.

Abstract

T ec h nology h a s ena b le d t h e ma ss p ro d uction of h y br i d an d electric ve h icle s. Intere s t in t h e s e alternative-ener g y ve h icle s h a s b een h eig h tene d d ue to air quality concern s in u rb an area s. H o w ever, t h e s e ve h icle s are ca p a b le of ve r y quiet o p e r ation , wh ic h coul d h ave negative s ide effect s on p e d e s trian an d d r iver s afety b ecau s e of t h e lac k of s ound cue s. A s urvey of 380 peo p le w a s conducte d to e xp lore intere s t and concern s a b out electrically p o w ere d ve h icle s. Th e data sh o w t h at t h e r e i s s u bs tantial p o s itive inte r e s t in d r iving quiet h y b ri d and electric car s. H o w ever , in t h e role of p e d e s trian , pa r ticipant s e x pre ss e d concern over t h e re d uced au d itory cue s to t h e pr e s ence of a moving ve h icle . Im p lication s of q uiet ve h icle s a r e d i s cu ss ed inclu d ing t h e ad d itional con s ideration of r educed d rive r a w arene ss of t h eir sp ee d. Precautionary mea s ure s and s ugge s tion s for effective engine noi s e s u bs titute s are p re s ented . INTRODUC T ION and wind (Robb i ns, 1995), t he r e may rema i n a The 1990 U.S. Environmental Protection threat to safety because of the lack of engine noise Agency's Clean Air Act required automotive normally attributed to gas-powered vehicles. manufacturers to build more part-gas, part-electric Relatively quiet vehicles will make position, speed (hybrid) and fully electric cars. The main purpose and direction cues less available to pedestrians. of the act was to improve air quality in urban areas Consequently, a greater frequency of pedestrian such as Southern Califomia, where smog has been a accidents can be anticipated involving quiet electric major problem. In fact, the state of California has vehicles. enacted its own low emission laws that are being Another potential problem with electric met, in part, by vehicles that are partially and fully vehicles concerns the driver's awareness of speed. electric. Clean-fuel vehicles have been shown to be Auditory cues indicative of greater speed are beneficial in reducing the amount of air pollution in reduced even further with sound insulation of the certain areas of the U.S. (Meotti, 1995). passenger compartment. Research suggests that The trend towards the use of electrically drivers with diminished hearing also have a powered vehicles could have some drawbacks. One diminished sensation of speed. More specifically, potential drawback is pedestrian safety.

Publication Details

Source
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
Volume
45

Publication Type

Conference Papers / Proceedings

View / Download Publication PDF

Copy / Export Citation

Download RIS  |  Download BibTeX

Exported citations use the available record metadata. Check formatting before academic use.