Punitive damages awards in civil litigation: Effects of profit information and amount of pain and suffering award
Publication Year:
2002
Citation
219. Laughery, K. R., Paige, D. L., Wogalter, M. S., & Bean, R. N. (2002). Punitive damages awards in civil litigation: Effects of profit information and amount of pain and suffering award. Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 46, 880-884.
Abstract
Richard N. Bean Department of Economics University of Houston Houston, TX 77204 USA A study addressing jury decisions regarding punitive damages awards i n civil litigation was carried out. Two issues explored were the fkct that jurors typically do not have a good metric for assigning a value to such damages and the concept of “leakage.” The latter concept refers to decisions regardii compensatory damages and punitive damages influencing each othery in the law they are supposed to be independent. Forty-two participants were given three scenarios describw accidents, injuries, liability outcomes, and the amounts of economic and non-economic (pain and suffering) awards. Their task was to decide on punitive damages awards. Two variables manipulated in the scenarios were the presence or absence of dekndant profit infbrmation and the amount (high or low) of the pain and sUgering award, Results indicated the main effects of the two variables were not statistically sisnificant. A si@Piticant interaction between the profit-information and pain-and-suffering-amount variables indicated that when profit information was availahle, low pain and suffering awards led to higher punitive damage awards. When profit information was not available, high pain and suffering awards l e d to higher punitive damage awards. The results indicate that decisions regarding compensatory and punitive damages are not independent as the law intends; an outcome that may be due, at least m part, to the uncertainty associated with these types of decisions. These findings have implications for judicial procedures, particularly jury instructions.
Publication Details
- Source
- Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Volume
- 46
Publication Type
Conference Papers / Proceedings
Research Topics
Forensic Human Factors
